It didn’t happen the same way for both of them. It didn’t look the same. It didn’t feel the same. But somehow, it led them to the same place.
For Joslyn Bricker, it started with a phone call, one conversation, unexpected, honest, and impossible to ignore. A future teammate from a Division I women’s basketball program was on the other end, explaining her decision to enter the transfer portal. What was meant to be a courtesy quickly became something more. As the conversation unfolded, so did a reality Joslyn hadn’t fully seen yet, one where rosters could turn over overnight, and relationships weren’t guaranteed.
By the time she hung up, something inside her had shifted.
“I started to realize what I thought I was going to be getting… was very different from the reality,” she said.
She went straight to her parents. What followed was not a quick decision; it was days of conversation, reflection, and prayer. There was pressure. There was guilt. There was the weight of walking away from something she had once dreamed about.
But there was also clarity.
“Playing Division I basketball looks cool,” she said. “But ultimately, I’m the one who has to live it out.”
For Vanessa Rosswurm, it was not a phone call. It was a quiet moment. Late June. A decision looming. A mind full of options, and no clear answer. She had opportunities. She had attention. She had every reason to follow the expected path. But none of that made the decision easier.
“I was very stressed and overwhelmed,” she said. “I didn’t know what I truly wanted.”
So she did something simple. She prayed. And in that moment, the answer came, not gradually, but clearly.
“So clear I almost second-guessed it,” she said.
Indiana Wesleyan.
For both of them, the decision meant stepping away from something.
For Joslyn, it meant letting go of a Division I commitment and the expectations that came with it. For Vanessa, it meant choosing a different path than what many assumed she would take. From the outside, those decisions might raise questions.
Why walk away from that level?
Why choose something else?
But for them, the answer was never about the level. It was about the life. They were looking for something harder to measure.
Consistency in a constantly changing landscape.
Relationships that would last longer than a season.
A culture that felt genuine, not transactional.
Vanessa saw clearly the difference between being recruited and being truly wanted. Coaches who did not just show up for games, but for her life. Conversations that went beyond basketball. A program that valued who she was becoming, not just what she could produce.
Joslyn felt it in the stability she could not find elsewhere. In a world shaped by transfers, NIL, and constant movement, she wanted something different.
“I wanted to be somewhere for four years,” she said. “To build relationships that actually last.”
Independently, they chose the same place.
Not because it was the easiest choice. Because it was the right one. Long before either decision was made, Ethan Whaley had seen something in both of them. Not just their talent, but their direction.
“The Fall of 2026 can’t get here fast enough,” he said. “I believe these players have a chance to leave a special legacy in a Wildcat uniform.”
And for him, it’s not about what shows up in a box score.
“They do not care about their statistics. They do not care about looking ‘cool.’ They care solely about maximizing their gifts so they can uplift and empower their teammates to thrive.”
That is what stood out. That is what made the decision make sense.
For Vanessa, it showed up in Indiana Wesleyan’s culture, with teammates growing together in faith and even planning mission trips before the season ever began—a program built on something deeper than basketball.
For Joslyn, it showed up in the people, coaches who invested in her long before the spotlight, teammates she could see herself growing alongside, and a place that felt right.
For both of them, it showed up in one word: Fit.
They didn’t just choose where to play. They chose who they wanted to become.
In a world that pushes athletes toward the biggest name or brightest spotlight, Joslyn Bricker and Vanessa Rosswurm chose something deeper: growth, purpose, faith, friendship, and peace in knowing they chose well at Indiana Wesleyan.
See related: Why Mental Health Support is a Competitive Advantage for Small Colleges
When tragedy struck an opposing player, Simpson University’s response showed that some things are bigger than football. There are moments in sports when the scoreboard becomes the least important thing in the stadium. For Simpson University (Calif.), one of those moments came during a football game against Mayville State (N.D.), when Comet’s quarterback Matt Donovan […]
At many small colleges and universities, football plays a significant role, both on the field and on the balance sheet. As the largest roster sport in the NAIA, football has a unique ability to influence enrollment, student retention, and institutional finances
At Carroll College (MT), character has never been just something celebrated on the sidelines. It has been built into the culture. As the NAIA’s inaugural School of Character, Carroll has long demonstrated what it means to make character an intentional part of the student-athlete experience. Now, that commitment has come full circle. Carroll student-athlete Henry […]
For most college basketball players, leaving the gym means leaving the coach behind. Jordan Brown isn’t most college basketball players. His coach is also his dad. Which means even when Jordan leaves the University of Saint Mary (Kan.) gym and heads back to campus, basketball has a funny way of staying in the family conversation. […]